By using ECSS site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
  • Home
  • International Relations
    International Relations
    Show More
    Top News
    A Conflict-free Africa: Silencing the Guns and Owning the Future
    June 14, 2020
    Isolationism and Infiltrating Society: The Brotherhood’s Dual Presence in the UK
    February 15, 2021
    The New Reality in Afghanistan: The US in Search of a New Strategy
    September 7, 2021
    Latest News
    Will India Grow into a Rising Asian Tiger?
    February 7, 2023
    Growing Engagement: Rivalry of Major Asian Powers in Africa
    February 5, 2023
    Looking West: India’s Strategy and Relations with Egypt
    February 4, 2023
    Messages from the Polisario Front’s 16th Congress
    February 1, 2023
  • Defense & Security
    Defense & Security
    Show More
    Top News
    Trump’s war on TikTok
    September 1, 2020
    الضربة الأولى: انطلاق الاجتياح الروسي لأوكرانيا
    The First Strike: Russia Storms Ukraine
    February 27, 2022
    Strategic Shift: Iran’s role in Sanaa between Proxy Management and Direct Involvement
    November 7, 2020
    Latest News
    Reasons and Ramifications of Al-Shabaab’s Retreat from its Positions
    January 30, 2023
    Task Force 59: The New US Military Deployment Pattern in the Middle East
    November 30, 2022
    The Future of Relations between Al-Qaeda, Taliban and Islamic State After Al-Zawahiri’s Death
    August 27, 2022
    Israel’s Cyber ​​Dome: Hallmarks and Motives
    August 15, 2022
  • Public Policy
    Public Policy
    Show More
    Top News
    The Oil Market in the Shadow of Coronavirus: The Current Situation and Future Prospects
    September 10, 2020
    The New Administrative Capital: Egypt’s Promising Future
    October 6, 2021
    Accelerating Development: Maximizing the Role of the Private Sector
    September 19, 2022
    Latest News
    How will Forward Exchange Contracts Affect Egypt’s Market Stability?
    January 24, 2023
    Egypt’s Economic Gains from COP27
    December 14, 2022
    Global Crisis: Whither Inflation?
    December 8, 2022
    Climate Finance: Financial Resources and Investments to Address Climate Change
    December 4, 2022
  • Analysis
    • Analysis
    • Analytical article
    • Opinions Articles
  • Activities
    • Conferences
    • ECSS Agenda
    • Panel Discussion
    • Seminar
    • Workshops
  • ECSS Library
    • Books
    • Digital Editions
    • Periodicals
    • Special Editions
  • العربية
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022,
Reading: A Test of Democracy: Corruption and Violence Outbreak in South Africa
Share
Notification Show More
Latest News
Will India Grow into a Rising Asian Tiger?
International Relations
Strategic Assessment for Israel 2023
Opinions Articles
Growing Engagement: Rivalry of Major Asian Powers in Africa
International Relations
Looking West: India’s Strategy and Relations with Egypt
International Relations
Messages from the Polisario Front’s 16th Congress
International Relations
Aa
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
Aa
  • اللغة العربية
  • International Relations
  • Defense & Security
  • Special Edition
  • Public Policy
  • Analysis
  • Activities & Events
  • Home
  • اللغة العربية
  • Categories
    • International Relations
    • Defense & Security
    • Public Policy
    • Analysis
    • Special Edition
    • Activities & Events
    • Opinions Articles
  • Bookmarks
Follow US
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022, Powered by EgyptYo Business Services.
International Relations

A Test of Democracy: Corruption and Violence Outbreak in South Africa

Shaimaa Al-Baksh
Last updated: 2021/12/09 at 2:21 PM
Shaimaa Al-Baksh
Share
14 Min Read
A Test of Democracy: Corruption and Violence Outbreak in South Africa
SHARE

The flare of violence that raced across South Africa for the first time since Apartheid, particularly in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng provinces in July 2021, wasn’t merely a reflection of the polarization within the ruling African National Congress (ANC) party nor of the country’s economic and social poor conditions manifested in the widespread protests that later developed into violent riots after Pro- Zuma demonstrations went out against the backdrop of the Constitutional Court’s ruling ordering jailing him for involvement in corruption charges but was rather a revealing test for South Africa’s democratic model, being a shining example amid numerous instances of democratic transitions that stumbled in many sub-Saharan African countries.

South Africa’s Democratic Model

Of all democratic transformations in sub-Saharan Africa, South Africa’s model –adopted since the end of Apartheid and the ANC coming to power in 1994– posed an exception, with the country enjoying relative stability, principles of constitutional democracy being adhered to, and the army maintaining its professionalism shifting away from interference in politics. Unlike sub-Saharan African countries, South Africa didn’t see any military coups, maintained constitutional stability, and experienced an economic boom that qualified it to be one of the fastest growing economies in sub-Saharan Africa. Further, the country witnessed relative stability and a peaceful transfer of power despite the generated polarization and splits within the ruling party.

The year 2008 marked a significant milestone in the history of constitutional democracy in South Africa, where the considerable polarization within the ruling party resulted in the resignation of President Thabo Mbeki, the second president of South Africa who succeeded Nelson Mandela. Following a transitional period under Galema Motlanthe, the ANC elected Jacob Zuma as president and he took power from 2009-2018. In 2018, given the escalated polarization within the ANC and the widespread corruption, the party forced Zuma to resign which marked another landmark in the history of democracy in South Africa. Zuma was succeeded by the current President Cyril Ramaphosa, who pledged to eliminate corruption and prosecute those involved in it, including President Jacob Zuma.

Bringing Zuma to trial was the spark that ignited the fire and led to the expansion of violence in South Africa last July after Zuma was sentenced to 15 months in prison for refusal to comply with the judiciary and stand before the court. Between Zuma’s supporters, who threatened to destabilize the country if he was arrested, and supporters of incumbent Ramaphosa who accused Zuma’s supporters of blocking Ramaphosa’s institutional and economic reform, the recent events uncovered the imbalance of the South African model and the deteriorating economic and social conditions the country suffers. This situation revealed that the transformation that took place in the 1990s hadn’t put an end to racial inequality between the white and the black communities but rather took root in the social and economic environment, a situation that could be attributed to the structural imbalance the country inherited with the white community and a minority of the black elite that came to power in the mid-1990s controlling vital sectors of the economy while the vast majority of the population continued to suffer marginalization.

Irrespective of these political polarizations, the crisis carries within it dimensions of the economic crisis and vulnerability of the South African model adopted after Apartheid, a model that contributed to promoting inequality and the poor distribution of wealth and income. For their part, South Africans see that their country is not a failed state but it is the global economic model that is failed. For them, it is the global economic model that took South Africa to dwindling levels on the Gini index measuring income or wealth inequality within a nation or a social group.

In the last decade during Zuma’s tenure, the economic situation had worsened. Since 2011, the gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate has not exceeded 3 percent, with persistently high rates of unemployment and crime. Estimates indicate that the recent unrest cost the country R50 billions of its GDP. Losses of Durban’s businesses amounted to R1.5 billion in addition to property loss of R15 billion with 50,000 traders and 40,000 businesses impacted by violence. This economic situation affected 150,000 jobs leaving 1.5 million people jobless. 

A Test for the Democratic Model

The looting, theft, and vandalism of commercial centers and banks that KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng provinces  –where the city of Johannesburg and the capital Pretoria are located– posed a test for the political cohesion of the ruling party and the ethnic policies adopted by ethnic-base parties in South Africa.

The protests and cases of looting reflected the economic and social deprivation suffered by the black majority in South Africa, an outcome of mismanagement and corruption entrenched during Zuma’s rule, both exacerbated the suffering of the country which inherited a structural imbalance which consolidated inequality and the poor distribution of income and wealth, typical features of economic liberalism that dominated South Africa’s economy, rendering it one of the most prominent examples of economic inequality globally.

Indeed, the Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) program has only made the black elite richer, with investment opportunities curtailed in most regions of the country due to land policies that has yet to be reformed and corruption that extended to the productive and service sectors of the most prominent industrialized country in Africa.

Now, South Africa is suffering high unemployment rates standing at about 30 percent, with unemployment rates among youth reaching about 70 percent. This proves the failure of the NCP to achieve just and comprehensive national development Worse, the economic repercussions of the lockdown due to Covid-19 have exacerbated the economic crisis of South Africa.

Irreconcilability between promises to promote economic and social rights and the exacerbation of economic crisis, resulted in escalation of anger and a decline in the popularity of the ruling party. Further, suspicions of corruption led the ruling party to suffer dwindling popular support at the municipal level, as has been evidenced in the 2016 elections. When Ramaphosa assumed power, he couldn’t move forward with his program aimed at eliminating corruption and implementing institutional reform due to the resistance of Zuma loyalists’ and their control over most sectors. However, recently, Ramaphosa took a series of measures that transformed the NCP situation. In July 2020, he introduced changes to the regulations, allowing law enforcement agencies to use evidence presented to the State Fund Seizure Commission, making it easier to lay charges against officials.

By the time Zuma was indicted, anger had reached a boiling point among his loyalists. As Ramaphosa was defending the rule of law, the security sector, particularly the police and intelligence agencies, were paralyzed by corruption, nepotism, and political interference which affected the state’s ability to uphold the rule of law and prevent crime, posing another test for South Africa’s security and judicial institutions measuring the state’s ability to enforce law, abide by principles of impartiality and neutrality, and refrain from engaging in political polarization among members of the ruling party. Under no circumstances can the recent acts of violence negate the NCF’s failure in reducing inequalities and the growing unemployment and perhaps this situation is the reason for the repeated reform calls and demands for an income grant instead of a wealth tax in an attempt to address structural disparities and avoid further turmoil.    

Given the high levels of crime and impunity, South Africa needs to reform its police institutions and the politicized security sector in a way that would likely help citizens restore trust in the government. In the 2020 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) –an index that measures the perceived levels of public sector corruption – South Africa ranked 69th out of 180 countries and on the Global Peace Index (GPI), it ranked 123rd although it showed an improvement in the Internal Peace Index scores, particularly with regard to political terrorism, violence, and human rights violations, with the number of prison decreasing despite the continuing high rates of crime and the widespread violence in the country.

In the period between 2011 and 2018, unrest in the country increased by 86 percent, with the largest levels recorded in the period between 2017 and 2018, during Zuma’s tenure with student protests mounting.

Likewise, South Africa’s score on the African Governance Index saw a decline in all sub-indicators pertaining to security, rule of law, accountability, transparency, and anti-corruption. Among all countries on the index, South Africa was the only country witnessing a decline in human development over the last ten years. 

According to the 2020 Index of Economic Freedom, the South African economy remained on the list of non-free economies. This requires South Africa to regain momentum towards greater economic freedom by giving priority to improving the judicial system and confronting the ongoing stalemate in the labor market, with the need for the government to reconsider the Land Reform Act, particularly its “land confiscation without reimbursement” practice that hampers investment and development.

According to 2020 estimates, the budget deficit accounted for 4.9 percent of South Africa’s GDP while public debt accounted for 62.2 percent of it. In addition, the cost of obtaining electricity continued to rise, as corruption continued to surround the state-owned company, ESCOM, despite government promises to reform it.

Overall, despite the political and economic achievements of South Africa, Zuma’s capture of the state, the corruption charges in which family-owned companies and businessmen loyal to Zuma were involved, the involvement of businesses in financing electoral campaigns, and the 1990s arms deal in which Zuma was involved are all factors that contributed to derailing South Africa’s economic progress.

That said, corruption alone can’t be blamed for the entire challenges South Africa is facing. Inequality and the economic and social imbalance reveal the structural imbalance that can be attributed to the system inherited in the 1990s which requires an in-depth re-examination of the current economic and social structure, so as to spare the country further deterioration.

Related Posts

Will India Grow into a Rising Asian Tiger?

Growing Engagement: Rivalry of Major Asian Powers in Africa

Looking West: India’s Strategy and Relations with Egypt

Messages from the Polisario Front’s 16th Congress

TAGGED: Corruption, Democracy, Featured, South Africa
Shaimaa Al-Baksh December 9, 2021
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Telegram Email Copy Link Print

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest Articles

Will Sudan Make it Off the US Terrorism Blacklist?
International Relations October 1, 2020
Iran’s Cyberattack on Israel: Background and Significance
International Relations March 29, 2022
Pre-emptive Education and Protection towards a Violence-Free Childhood
Public Policy September 27, 2022
Reviving Luxor’s Avenue of the Sphinxes: A New Cultural and Tourist Attraction
Reviving Luxor’s Avenue of the Sphinxes: A New Cultural and Tourist Attraction
Public Policy December 14, 2021

Latest Tweets

International Relations

  • African Studies
  • American Studies
  • Arab & Regional Studies
  • Asian Studies
  • European Studies
  • Palestinian & Israeli Studies

Defence & Security

  • Armament
  • Cyber Security
  • Extremism
  • Terrorism & Armed Conflict

Public Policies

  • Development & Society
  • Economic & Energy Studies
  • Egypt & World Stats
  • Media Studies
  • Public Opinion
  • Women & Family Studies

The Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies is an independent non-profit think tank, providing decisions-makers by Policy alternatives, the center was establised in 2018 and comprises a group of experts and researchers from diffrent generations and scientific desciplines. 

All Rights Reserved to Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies - ECSS © 2022

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?