By using ECSS site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
  • Home
  • International Relations
    International Relations
    Show More
    Top News
    Egypt-France relations: Consensus and strategic partnership
    December 12, 2020
    Beyond Tigray: Wielding Hunger as a Weapon in Ethiopia’s Civil War
    August 22, 2021
    Cautious Trepidation: The International and Regional Response to the Ethiopian Crisis
    February 9, 2022
    Latest News
    Deteriorating Security Crises: Renewed Risks of Civil War in Darfur
    June 10, 2023
    Iran-Mauritania Rapprochement: Motives and Objectives
    June 6, 2023
    The Political Aspects of France’s Crisis
    June 4, 2023
    The UNITAMS Role and the Position of Sudanese Parties 
    June 3, 2023
  • Defense & Security
    Defense & Security
    Show More
    Top News
    A Habitual Trend: Terrorist Organizations’ Exploitation of Natural Disasters
    March 25, 2023
    Why isn’t the Yemen war drawing to a close?
    March 27, 2021
    Israel’s Cyber ​​Dome: Hallmarks and Motives
    Israel’s Cyber ​​Dome: Hallmarks and Motives
    August 15, 2022
    Latest News
    Why Have TikTok Security Concerns Grown Globally?
    April 16, 2023
    Employing Loopholes: Escalating Pakistani Taliban Activity and its Repercussions
    April 1, 2023
    A Habitual Trend: Terrorist Organizations’ Exploitation of Natural Disasters
    March 25, 2023
    ChatGPT: Promising Applications, Potential Difficulties
    March 6, 2023
  • Public Policy
    Public Policy
    Show More
    Top News
    Unprecedented Revival: Egypt’s Becomes Self-Sufficient in Natural Gas
    August 29, 2021
    A Comprehensive Vision: The Cultural and Touristic Dimensions of Developing Muhammad Ali’s Gunpowder Magazine
    A Comprehensive Vision: The Cultural and Touristic Dimensions of Developing Muhammad Ali’s Gunpowder Magazine
    June 21, 2022
    Effective Policies: Managing Inflation in Egypt in 2021
    February 8, 2022
    Latest News
    Boosting Presence: The Economic Implications of Iranian President’s Visit to Syria
    May 27, 2023
    Scenarios for Energy Crisis Management in the European Union
    May 20, 2023
    Reading into Egypt’s Foreign Debt
    May 13, 2023
    Development Trends in Sinai
    May 2, 2023
  • Analysis
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Situation Assessment
    • Readings
  • Activities
    • Conferences
    • ECSS Agenda
    • Panel Discussion
    • Seminar
    • Workshops
  • ECSS Library
    • Books
    • Digital Editions
    • Periodicals
    • Special Editions
  • العربية
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022,
Reading: The Israeli Question – Again
Share
Notification Show More
Latest News
Deteriorating Security Crises: Renewed Risks of Civil War in Darfur
African Studies Others
Tunnels of Religious War in Palestine
Opinion
Iran-Mauritania Rapprochement: Motives and Objectives
European Studies
The Political Aspects of France’s Crisis
European Studies
The UNITAMS Role and the Position of Sudanese Parties 
African Studies
Aa
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
Aa
  • اللغة العربية
  • International Relations
  • Defense & Security
  • Special Edition
  • Public Policy
  • Analysis
  • Activities & Events
  • Home
  • اللغة العربية
  • Categories
    • International Relations
    • Defense & Security
    • Public Policy
    • Analysis
    • Special Edition
    • Activities & Events
    • Opinions Articles
  • Bookmarks
Follow US
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022, Powered by EgyptYo Business Services.
Opinions Articles

The Israeli Question – Again

Dr. Abdel Moneim Said
Last updated: 2023/04/13 at 8:58 PM
Dr. Abdel Moneim Said
Share
10 Min Read
SHARE

On 28 December 2022, I wrote an opinion piece titled “The Israeli Question”. The article’s primary perspective is grounded in the “Palestinian issue”, from which the dynamics between Arabs and Israelis emerge. It drew heavily from a New York Times piece titled “What in the world is happening in Israel?” in which the author described the multifaceted dynamics at play in the territory spanning the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea, categorizing them into four groups: Jewish-Jewish, Israeli-Arab Jewish, Jewish-Palestinian, and Palestinian-Palestinian.

Surprisingly, our article focused on the last three interactions, but the first one between Jews and Jews shows the heart of the “Israeli issue” that came up in recent weeks when the Israeli arena exploded with protests against the Israeli government’s attempt to limit the Supreme Court’s powers so that it is under the control of the legislature (the Knesset) and thus the majority enjoyed by the current government coalition led by Benjamin Netanyahu.

After nearly two months of demonstrations in which over 600,000 people took part, we learn that the Israeli public could not find a “democratic” way to express its rejection of the Netanyahu government’s attempt to subjugate the Supreme Court to the authority of the Knesset other than to take to the streets. Obviously, the government sought to do this in order to prevent recourse to a higher authority in the event of a violation of the country’s fundamental laws by creating a huge power disparity between the executive branch, which holds the majority in parliament, and the judiciary.

Here, we discover that Israel’s lack of a constitution is the fundamental problem. Instead of a constitution, the country has a kind of basic law that was enacted upon the founding of the state and is based on a temporary agreement on fundamental principles that uphold secularism. The religious group in the government wants to change this by switching from human law to the Jewish “Sharia”. The Israeli division prompted references to “civil war” and parallels between Israel and Lebanon. After striking and protesting reached a fever pitch and the defense minister was fired, Netanyahu conceded to postpone a vote on the judicial reform plan.

The current crisis has its origins in 2018, when Israel suddenly declared itself to be “the nation-state of the Jewish people,” a claim which was subsequently ratified by the Knesset. This move was connected to others, such as the declaration of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital or the rapid growth of settlements on land bordering the West Bank. A quarter-century ago, let alone seven decades ago, it was inconceivable that the Hebrew state would take these steps.

This situation illustrates the Israeli imperial audacity that drives it to pursue religious aspirations that were previously dismissed as illogical. What turns these into more than pipe dreams is the existence of a network of ultraconservative currents from which no country is immune. More importantly, these currents continue to generate fresh ideas that will soon join their predecessors in the mainstream of Israeli politics,   including primarily the annexation of the occupied Syrian Golan Heights to Israel, as well as the annexation of the West Bank lands used for Israeli settlements, as a step toward annexing the vast majority of the West Bank’s lands, which are designated as Area C. These actions stem from the core beliefs of Israeli Salafism, which advocates basing Israeli law on the biblical Sharia in dealing with the state and its over 21 percent Arab population.

Those who have been keeping tabs on the Hebrew state ever since its inception know that there are schisms within the country, the most common one being between Ashkenazi Jews from Europe and Sephardic Jews from Arab and Middle Eastern countries, a schism that is based on ethnicity, religion, socioeconomic status, and politics.

There was also a schism between the Labor and Likud parties, representing the left and right, as well as between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, or, in short, between liberals and conservatives. The state’s secularism and basic law had nothing to do with these schisms, but in the last decade or so, a third sect entered the fray: Salafists, who view Israel through the lens of the Torah, which claims all land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea as Jewish property, making peace with the Palestinians impossible.

More importantly, the Jewish people who live in this region must be true Jews according to the strict interpretations of Jewish law. When compared to the Salafist groups that swept the Middle East during the so-called Arab Spring, the current government coalition in Israel doesn’t look too different. This time, it manifests in what might be described as the Israeli Spring, which is based on the same customs of meddling in the private lives of citizens regarding their attire, diet, marriages, and funerals.

Perhaps this explains, in large part, the outcry of the parties and Israeli civil society, who believed that the electoral process had produced results that sought to alter the nature of the state in a manner not dissimilar to what transpired in Arab countries after the Muslim Brotherhood and its allies gained control of those countries. Maybe this is the exact reason why the Jews in Washington and the capitals of Europe were so anxious. They were confronted with a form of Jewish Orthodox fundamentalism that was different from the “reformist” current that was dominant among Jews in Europe and America. What is surprising is that the rise of Jewish Salafism in Israel occurred after Arab reformist currents were successful in battling Salafist currents, either by keeping them out of power or by going to war when they evolved into terrorist organizations.

Does this imply that a confrontation between the reformist “demonstrators” and the Israeli administration, which has approved the development of a new militia for the National Guard that can be used domestically and against Israeli citizens, is unavoidable? In fact, at this point in Israeli politics’ evolution, it is challenging to answer this question. Netanyahu’s retreat and temporary acceptance of abandoning his attempt to overthrow the judiciary cannot be ignored anyway.

However, the nature of Jewish Salafism, or even earlier Arab Salafism, could not permit such a brief lull. This situation will probably be used by Netanyahu and the Likud party to evaluate the Salafist faction in the ruling coalition. Netanyahu is not the person who infuriates Jews, American and European governments. Nevertheless, he also has another choice: he could send the entire Israeli political elite back to the polls in the hopes of gaining more popular support that would enable him to carry out his agenda. This might buy more time, and the Arab minority might have a role to play in tipping the scales, but the future will be filled with challenging possibilities.

This article was originally published in Arabic on 5 April 2023 in the Asharq Al-Awsat newspaper.

Related Posts

African Peace Initiative to End Russia-Ukraine Conflict

Drones and the Kremlin Bring Back Excitement to the Ukraine War

A Fresh Eye on the Sudanese Issue

Russia’s Position in the Syrian-Turkish Settlement

Dr. Abdel Moneim Said April 13, 2023
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Telegram Email Copy Link Print
Dr. Abdel Moneim Said
By Dr. Abdel Moneim Said
Head of the Advisory Board

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest Articles

Latent Escalation: Will Calm in the Eastern Mediterranean Last in 2022?
International Relations January 20, 2022
Iran’s Cyberattack on Israel: Background and Significance
International Relations March 29, 2022
The Middle East and the Democrats
Analysis November 19, 2020
France’s two summits: Egyptian and French efforts to support Sudanese and African economies
International Relations June 5, 2021

Latest Tweets

International Relations

  • African Studies
  • American Studies
  • Arab & Regional Studies
  • Asian Studies
  • European Studies
  • Palestinian & Israeli Studies

Defence & Security

  • Armament
  • Cyber Security
  • Extremism
  • Terrorism & Armed Conflict

Public Policies

  • Development & Society
  • Economic & Energy Studies
  • Egypt & World Stats
  • Media Studies
  • Public Opinion
  • Women & Family Studies

The Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies is an independent non-profit think tank, providing decisions-makers by Policy alternatives, the center was establised in 2018 and comprises a group of experts and researchers from diffrent generations and scientific desciplines. 

All Rights Reserved to Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies - ECSS © 2022

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?