By using ECSS site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
  • Home
  • International Relations
    International Relations
    Show More
    Top News
    German-French Relations: A Tug of War
    January 5, 2023
    The Tigray crisis: The Cost of Instability in Ethiopia
    November 18, 2020
    The ethnic crisis of Qemant: The complex reality of Ethiopia’s Amhara
    July 31, 2021
    Latest News
    Regional Breakthrough: The Geopolitical Implications of the Saudi-Iranian Agreement
    March 29, 2023
    Expanding Financial Inclusion in Egypt with InstaPay
    March 28, 2023
    Heated Competition: Syria’s Phosphate and Russian-Iranian Spheres of Influence
    March 22, 2023
    Structural Causes of Economic Decline in South Africa
    March 18, 2023
  • Defense & Security
    Defense & Security
    Show More
    Top News
    Coping with Challenges:
    ISIS from Operation Kayla Mueller to the Syria Earthquake
    March 4, 2023
    Strategic Shift: Iran’s role in Sanaa between Proxy Management and Direct Involvement
    November 7, 2020
    Political Considerations: The Motives and Implications of Lifting Five Foreign Terrorist Organizations off US Terrorist List
    Political Considerations: The Motives and Implications of Lifting Five Foreign Terrorist Organizations off US Terrorist List
    May 28, 2022
    Latest News
    A Habitual Trend: Terrorist Organizations’ Exploitation of Natural Disasters
    March 25, 2023
    ChatGPT: Promising Applications, Potential Difficulties
    March 6, 2023
    Coping with Challenges:
    ISIS from Operation Kayla Mueller to the Syria Earthquake
    March 4, 2023
    Reasons and Ramifications of Al-Shabaab’s Retreat from its Positions
    January 30, 2023
  • Public Policy
    Public Policy
    Show More
    Top News
    Radical Overhaul: Egypt’s Plan to Upgrade the Railway Network
    August 21, 2021
    Fruitful Efforts: Egypt’s National Agricultural Projects and Achieving Self-Sufficiency
    June 1, 2022
    The Law of General Average: Ever Given Compensation Crisis
    August 19, 2021
    Latest News
    Imminent Challenges: Hunger and Global Food Security Disruption
    March 14, 2023
    How will Forward Exchange Contracts Affect Egypt’s Market Stability?
    January 24, 2023
    Egypt’s Economic Gains from COP27
    December 14, 2022
    Global Crisis: Whither Inflation?
    December 8, 2022
  • Analysis
    • Analysis
    • Analytical article
    • Opinions Articles
  • Activities
    • Conferences
    • ECSS Agenda
    • Panel Discussion
    • Seminar
    • Workshops
  • ECSS Library
    • Books
    • Digital Editions
    • Periodicals
    • Special Editions
  • العربية
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022,
Reading: The Conflict of Visions on GERD
Share
Notification Show More
Latest News
Regional Breakthrough: The Geopolitical Implications of the Saudi-Iranian Agreement
Arab & Regional Studies
Expanding Financial Inclusion in Egypt with InstaPay
International Relations
Marking the Day Egypt Restored Taba, and the Challenges Ahead
Opinions Articles
A Habitual Trend: Terrorist Organizations’ Exploitation of Natural Disasters
Terrorism & Armed Conflict
The World is Changing
Opinions Articles
Aa
ECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic StudiesECSS - Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies
Aa
  • اللغة العربية
  • International Relations
  • Defense & Security
  • Special Edition
  • Public Policy
  • Analysis
  • Activities & Events
  • Home
  • اللغة العربية
  • Categories
    • International Relations
    • Defense & Security
    • Public Policy
    • Analysis
    • Special Edition
    • Activities & Events
    • Opinions Articles
  • Bookmarks
Follow US
  • Advertise
All Rights Reserved to ECSS © 2022, Powered by EgyptYo Business Services.
International Relations

The Conflict of Visions on GERD

Dr. Hassan Abu Taleb
Last updated: 2020/06/15 at 9:23 AM
Dr. Hassan Abu Taleb
Share
9 Min Read
SHARE

Even though relations between Egypt and Ethiopia have generally improved in the past four years, progress in the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) issue has been moving in the opposite direction. The warmer relationship between the two countries is not reflecting on efforts to reach an agreement on the filling of the reservoir in its first few years and the permanent operation of the dam without harming the interests and rights of the two downstream countries.

Such an agreement requires transparency, cooperation and the continual exchange of information about the rates of water flow and rainfall. To Egyptians, the Nile water is a matter of life.

President Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi sounded the alarm bells during his participation in the 74th round of the United Nations General Assembly, held in September. He pointed out to the lack of agreement on the GERD issue and its negative repercussions on Nile Basin countries, foremost among which on the lives of Egyptians.

President Al-Sisi said Egypt didn’t accept imposed realities. His remarks were a direct expression of worry concerning Ethiopia’s refusal of the Egyptian proposals on the rules to fill and operate the dam in a flexible way dependent on floods and the amount of rainfall each year at a time, as well as Ethiopia’s rejection to discuss the matter scientifically, at least.

Egypt has put the GERD crisis within not a political, but a scientific framework that focuses on the possible scenarios for the filling of the dam. Egypt demands being involved in the management of the dam in a manner that allows Ethiopia to benefit from the generation of electricity and agricultural expansion resulting from building the dam, and at the same time preserves Egypt and Sudan’s water rights.

This is the formula President Al-Sisi has been stressing since he was sworn in in 2014. The formula is based on accepting the dam as a regional development project and preserving Egypt and Sudan’s rights to Nile water. Practically, Egypt would shoulder some damage, provided that it be under control.

In application of this policy, Egypt suggested the participation of experts from the World Bank in the negotiations to present solutions accepted by the three parties. Ethiopia refused. Egypt recently demanded the mediation of the international community via the United Nations or US mediation. Again, Ethiopia refused.

On the other hand, Ethiopia’s stance is based on the concept of sovereignty, believing that since the Blue Nile passes through it, it has the right to benefit from it according to its interests and priorities, before looking to the interests of the downstream countries. In other words, it believes the Blue Nile is an Ethiopian river first and foremost, and whatever remains of its water is not up to downstream countries to decide or regulate.

Based on this Ethiopian stance, it refused to share information about the rates of water flow, the technical details of the GERD, and its plan to manage it according to the rainfall rate.

In the same context, and based on the history of Ethiopian politics regarding the River Nile, Ethiopia refuses to sign agreements on dealing with the river water on a regional level. It rejects the agreements of 1929 and 1959 that determine Egypt and Sudan’s right to Nile water, believing that they are not its concern, basing its argument on the rhetoric that it was not part of the deals.

Ethiopia believes the Declaration of Principles signed with Egypt and Sudan in Khartoum in March 2015 and the 1993 agreement signed by former Egypt president Hosni Mubarak and former prime minister of Ethiopia Meles Zenawi are both a set of general principles that express good will, but that the application of these principles primarily depends on Ethiopia’s vision.

The Egyptian and Ethiopian visions lie at the opposite ends of the spectrum, each of them rejecting the other. The question here is whether the general improvements in bilateral relations can solve the crisis and what Egypt can do to preserve its interests and historic rights to Nile water.

It is obvious the relative improvement in the economic file and contacts between high-level officials from the two countries are so far irrelative to the GERD issue. It may even seem that Cairo’s interest to develop its relations with Addis Ababa and other Nile Basin countries is misunderstood as weakness on the part of Egypt. President Al-Sisi alluded to this at the youth conference held in September, saying that the fall of a state, just like what happened in Egypt after 2011, allows other countries to disregard its water rights. He referred to Iraq, which used to annually receive 100 billion cubic meters of water and now receives 30 billion cubic meters.

It also appears that the binding Declaration of Principles of 2015, comprising 10 principles derived from international law, concerning the effect of the GERD on downstream countries, is ringing hollow in Ethiopia’s ears. Ethiopia is interpreting the principles, some of which sentences are loosely termed, in a different way.

The more difficult question is, what will Egypt do to preserve its rights and shoulder the least possible damages? 

Noteworthy to mention is that any military action on the part of Egypt is out of the question due to practical and humanitarian reasons. Putting the military option on the table will reap negative repercussions not only to Ethiopia but all the countries of the Nile Basin, which is not what Egypt wants.

This is why negotiations remain within an active political and diplomatic circle. The negotiations shall reap benefits on three conditions: Africa’s understanding of Egypt’s fears, which will put pressure on Ethiopia to adopt more lenient positions; more coordination with Sudan, that doesn’t look like it has recovered from the policies of the overthrown Omar Al-Bashir regime; and that the GERD file and Ethiopia’s intransigence become a fixture in Egypt’s relations with other countries.

The understanding and support of powerful Arab countries to Egypt’s water rights will undoubtedly reflect positively on the lives of Egyptians.

This article was published first in: The Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies, The Gran Ethiopian Renaissance Dam Crisis: dimensions, Repercussions and Future Courses, Especial Edition, October 2019.

Related Posts

Regional Breakthrough: The Geopolitical Implications of the Saudi-Iranian Agreement

Expanding Financial Inclusion in Egypt with InstaPay

Heated Competition: Syria’s Phosphate and Russian-Iranian Spheres of Influence

Structural Causes of Economic Decline in South Africa

TAGGED: Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi, Declaration of Principles, Egypt, Ethiopia, GERD, Sudan, The Nile
Dr. Hassan Abu Taleb June 15, 2020
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Telegram Email Copy Link Print
Dr. Hassan Abu Taleb
By Dr. Hassan Abu Taleb
Advisory Board Member & Training Unit Supervisor

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest Articles

The Killing of Maher Al-Aqal: IS’ Leadership Crisis
Analysis July 26, 2022
Trump’s war on TikTok
Defense & Security September 1, 2020
Case of immigration in Ethiopia: why do people flee?
Case of immigration in Ethiopia: why do people flee?
International Relations January 22, 2022
Political Considerations: The Motives and Implications of Lifting Five Foreign Terrorist Organizations off US Terrorist List
Political Considerations: The Motives and Implications of Lifting Five Foreign Terrorist Organizations off US Terrorist List
Defense & Security May 28, 2022

Latest Tweets

International Relations

  • African Studies
  • American Studies
  • Arab & Regional Studies
  • Asian Studies
  • European Studies
  • Palestinian & Israeli Studies

Defence & Security

  • Armament
  • Cyber Security
  • Extremism
  • Terrorism & Armed Conflict

Public Policies

  • Development & Society
  • Economic & Energy Studies
  • Egypt & World Stats
  • Media Studies
  • Public Opinion
  • Women & Family Studies

The Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies is an independent non-profit think tank, providing decisions-makers by Policy alternatives, the center was establised in 2018 and comprises a group of experts and researchers from diffrent generations and scientific desciplines. 

All Rights Reserved to Egyptian Center for Strategic Studies - ECSS © 2022

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?